AgNook.com
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Livestock
    • Crops
    • Business & Inputs
  • Markets
    • Market News
    • Market Analysis
  • Livestock
    • Cattle
    • Hogs & Pigs
  • Lifestyle
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Livestock
    • Crops
    • Business & Inputs
  • Markets
    • Market News
    • Market Analysis
  • Livestock
    • Cattle
    • Hogs & Pigs
  • Lifestyle
No Result
View All Result
AgNook.com
No Result
View All Result
Home News Business & Inputs

Iowa Fights Back in ‘Ag-Gag’ Law Ruling

Iowa appealed the federal ruling which deemed the state's law was unconstitutional

AgNook Editor posted by AgNook Editor
March 28, 2019
in Business & Inputs, News
0
Iowa Fights Back Ag Nook

Iowa Fights Back Ag Nook

0
SHARES
949
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

In January, a federal judge ruled against Iowa’s law which made it illegal to go undercover at agricultural operations. The 2012 law was deemed a violation of the First Amendment. Animal activists across the country rejoiced. However, Iowa isn’t done yet.

2012 Law

Iowa is the top pork producing state in the nation. The 2012 law was created after several investigations brought national attention to Iowa’s agricultural industry. They created the crime of “agricultural production facility fraud” because of this negative attention.

There were multiple undercover investigations of Iowa farms documenting mistreatment of animals.

At least some of those investigations were carried out by people who took the jobs in order to expose mistreatment of animals, said James Gritzner, senior judge of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa.

Following these investigations, the Iowa Legislature began considering passage of a new law. This law would make it illegal for anyone to obtain access to an agricultural production facility “by false pretenses.” Essentially, it criminalized all undercover operations by journalists and activists.

According to The Associated Press, no undercover investigations had taken place in Iowa since the law was approved.

January Ruling

In January, a federal judge in Iowa ruled it was no longer a crime to go undercover at any agricultural operation. He deemed it a violation of First Amendment Rights.

The Animal Legal Defense Fund served as one of the plaintiffs in the case. Elated with the ruling, they called it a “win for free speech and animal protection.”

“Ag-Gag laws are a pernicious attempt by animal exploitation industries to hide some of the worst forms of animal abuse in the United States,” ALDF Executive Director Stephen Wells said in a statement. “Today’s victory makes it clear that the government cannot protect these industries at the expense of our constitutional rights.”

However, others had very opposite reactions to this ruling.

“It was never the intent of farmers to infringe on others’ constitutional rights,” the Iowa Pork Producers Association said. “We were relying on the courts to help us protect our rights to lawfully conduct our businesses and care for our animals.”

Iowa lawmakers said the law responded to two major concerns the agriculture industry faces. In this case, it responded to facility security, and reputational harm sometimes accompanying investigative reporting.

“What we’re aiming at is stopping these groups that go out and gin up campaigns that they use to raise money by trying to give the agriculture industry a bad name,” then-state Sen. Tom Rielly said at the time.

The two opposing sides went to battle. Those opposing the law said it was an infringement on protections offered to journalists by the First Amendment. Conversely, Iowa lawmakers said the law was enacted to defend the private property rights of Iowans who own agricultural facilities.

Therefore, the question remained – is taking a job under false pretenses protected by the First Amendment?

Unfortunate Ruling

After the hearing in January, the federal judge ruled the law was a violation of the First Amendment. In a sense, lies were being protected by the First Amendment.

“To some degree, the concept of constitutional protection for speech that is false may be disquieting,” Gritzner wrote.

Grizner continued and quoted the U.S. Supreme Court.

He said, “the Nation well knows that one of the costs of the First Amendment is that it protects the speech we detest as well as the speech we embrace.”

While activists praised the ruling, agriculturalists now fear what could come of this. However, Iowa isn’t giving up.

Read more at npr.org

Iowa Fights Back

Despite the disheartening ruling, Iowa isn’t backing down without a fight. Recently, Iowa’s Attorney General, Tom Miller, filed an appeal to this ruling. He filed to have the case moved to the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. Additionally, he filed a motion to have the law kept in place pending the appeal.

“Defendants respectfully submit there is substantial ground for difference of opinion, and thus a reasonable likelihood of success, as to whether Iowa’s Ag-Fraud statute restricts protected speech in violation of the First Amendment,” the filing states. “The Supreme Court has held false speech that imposes a legally cognizable harm or provides a material gain to the speaker is not protected under the First Amendment.”

Similarly, laws in other states such as Idaho and Utah have been overturned based on the First Amendment. However, challenges to the those laws in several other states are continuing.

Read more at meatingplace.com

Summary

A law in effect since 2012 was recently overturned by the federal court. As a result, animal rights activists will be allowed to enter agricultural operations under false pretenses. However, Iowa has not given up yet. Miller recently filed an appeal. While many other states are going through similar situations, it is hopeful Iowa can serve as the turning point.

Tags: Ag Gag LawAnimal Legal Defense Fundanimal rightsanimal rights activistsIowaIowa legislatureIowa Pork Producer's AssociationTom Miller

Previous Article

Trump Approves Disaster Aid for Iowa and Nebraska

Next Article

Chinese Trade Talks Resume, but Don't Hold Your Breath

Related Content

More Trade Aid on the Way
Business & Inputs

More Trade Aid on the Way

November 11, 2019
Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling
Livestock

Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling

September 28, 2019
Trump Delays China Tariff Increase
Business & Inputs

Trump Delays China Tariff Increase

September 12, 2019
Farmers on “Freeze Watch”
Crops

Farmers on “Freeze Watch”

September 10, 2019
Pork Shortage Ag Nook
Livestock

China Develops New Solution for Pork Shortage

August 21, 2019
African Swine Fever Preparation Ag Nook
Livestock

States Arm Themselves With Knowledge When It Comes to African Swine Fever Preparation

July 31, 2019
Next Article
Chinese Trade Talks Resume, but Don’t Hold Your Breath

Chinese Trade Talks Resume, but Don't Hold Your Breath

Newsletter

newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for AgNook top stories each week!

Top Stories

More Trade Aid on the Way

More Trade Aid on the Way

November 11, 2019
Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling

Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling

September 28, 2019
Suicide Prevention Ag Nook

Farmers are Suffering and It’s Time to Take Action

September 14, 2019
Trump Delays China Tariff Increase

Trump Delays China Tariff Increase

September 12, 2019
Farmers on “Freeze Watch”

Farmers on “Freeze Watch”

September 10, 2019

Trending

Used Ag Equipment Baler JD 1000 Ag Nook

Used Ag Equipment on the Move

May 1, 2018
Sorghum Blue Skies with China Trade Tensions Residing Ag Nook

The Busy Grower’s Brief About China’s Sorghum Anti-Dumping Relief

May 21, 2018
Maximize Profits on Late Planting

Maximize Profits on Late Planting

June 13, 2019
Get Started with Cover Crops

Get Started with Cover Crops

May 5, 2018
Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

April 15, 2018

Most Popular in the last week

Farmers for Trump Ag Nook

Trump Won’t Leave American Farmers Behind

July 17, 2018
In defense of ‘factory’ farming & ‘industrial, big ag’

In defense of ‘factory’ farming & ‘industrial, big ag’

February 27, 2018
Cattle Grazing Systems AgNook

The Secret to Successful Grazing

November 15, 2018
More research shows environmental benefits of AMP grazing

More research shows environmental benefits of AMP grazing

March 19, 2018
Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

April 15, 2018
Facebook Twitter
AgNook.com

  • Terms of Use
  • Contact
  • About AgNook
  • Advertise With AgNook
newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for AgNook top stories each week!

© 2018 AgNook, LLC

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Livestock
    • Crops
    • Business & Inputs
  • Markets
    • Market News
    • Market Analysis
  • Livestock
    • Cattle
    • Hogs & Pigs
  • Lifestyle

© 2018 AgNook, LLC

Don't miss out on AgNook top stories!
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our top news stories sent right to your inbox!