AgNook.com
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Livestock
    • Crops
    • Business & Inputs
  • Markets
    • Market News
    • Market Analysis
  • Livestock
    • Cattle
    • Hogs & Pigs
  • Lifestyle
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Livestock
    • Crops
    • Business & Inputs
  • Markets
    • Market News
    • Market Analysis
  • Livestock
    • Cattle
    • Hogs & Pigs
  • Lifestyle
No Result
View All Result
AgNook.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Livestock

Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling

Proposed manure storage regulations are another challenge for diaries

AgNook Editor posted by AgNook Editor
September 28, 2019
in Cattle, Livestock, Livestock
0
Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling

Wisconsin governor Tony Evers.

0
SHARES
2.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The state of Wisconsin under governor Tony Evers has recognized that it has a problem with water quality and air quality. The state is moving forward to make improvements. Evers declared 2019 as the “Year of clean drinking water,” and has targeted the dairy industry as one of the sources of pollution problems. The state has proposed tighter regulations on how manure on dairies can be stored. Even though the regulations haven’t yet passed, the diary industry isn’t happy about it.

Proposed Manure Storage Regulations

According to WXOW and a recent story from the Associated Press, the dairy industry upset that new regulations over manure storage on factory farms might be on the way. Agriculture officials in the state are writing new standards for farms that will serve as templates for local ordinances, and it’s looking like they will be more restrictive.

Farms with more than 1,000 animals or more will have to place manure storage facilities at least 1,000 to 2,500 feet from their neighbors’ properties. The rule is designed to help minimize odors.

Dairy Industry Isn’t Happy

Many farm groups like the Dairy Business Association, the Wisconsin Dairy Alliance, the Wisconsin Dairy Products Association and Wisconsin Farm Bureau Federation held a news conference recently, and they all emphasized how detrimental the potential regulation could be to factory farms. They argue that it makes expansion nearly impossible and will push dairies out of Wisconsin.

Read more at wxow.com

“Year of Clean Drinking Water”

Todd Richmond of the Associated Press wrote a piece covering the proposed manure storage restrictions. He reports that this has been an ongoing project begun by Wisconsin governor Tony Evers. His administration has been taking steps to restrict manure storage as a way to minimize odors and water pollution. Ever since Evers declared 2019 as the “Year of clean drinking water” his administration has been working to provide tighter manure regulations for local governments to implement.

Last year the state Department of Natural Resources imposed restrictions on manure-spreading in 15 northeastern Wisconsin counties due to drinking water contamination.

Contaminated Wells

A scope statement outlining the potential rule changes for the Southwestern part of the state was released in mid-September. It’s hoped that the restrictions will help improve water quality and pollution. The US Agricultural Research Service and the Wisconsin Geological and Natural History Survey released a study in August that has likely prompted the action. The study found that 32 of 35 wells tested in Grant, Iowa and Lafayette counties contained fecal matter from humans or livestock.

Jennifer Giegerich, a lobbyist for the League of Wisconsin Conservation Voters is pushing for changes.

“The current manure practices we have do not protect our drinking water,” Giegerich said. “Expanding these protections to areas of the state with nitrate contamination problems is necessary.”

Struggling Dairies

The proposal is likely to run into opposition not only from the dairy industry, but also Republican lawmakers in the state. They currently control the state legislature. Farmers are an important GOP constituency and they’re currently facing all sorts of problems: the trade war, dropping milk prices, and increased numbers of factory farms. Almost 700 Wisconsin dairy farms closed last year and net cash farm income dropped 22% between 2012 and 2017 according to the National Agricultural Statistics Service.

Needless to say, Wisconsin dairy farmers are struggling, and this proposed regulation in particular will only make things harder for them. There’s only so much land to spread manure. The new restrictions might force dairy farmers to rent or buy more land for spreading. Farmers may also begin injecting manure into the soil. This practice helps prevent runoff, but is costly because it requires special equipment.

Stakeholders will have many opportunities to share their opinions on the proposed restrictions. The Wisconsin DNR will hold their first of many public hearings in October.

Read more at apnews.com

Regulations Will Be Tough to Implement

Todd Richmond of the AP covered another part of the story that was published in the News Times. Richmond reports that Wisconsin Senator Steve Nass, the co-chairman of the Legislature’s rules committee, says that the department “bureaucrats” are ignoring the dairy industry’s concerns and will block the rules if they reach the committee in their current form.

Nass says that the proposed regulations are just too tough.

“It would be a terrible mistake for (the department) to formally submit their current version of rule changes to the Legislature,” Nass said. “Instead, the department should scrap their current process and begin anew, this time seeking to work cooperatively with the widest representation of Wisconsin’s agricultural community. However, if the agency prefers the route of confrontation, then that is what they will get from the Legislature and farmers of this state.”

The Wisconsin Dairy Alliance had dire predictions if the regulations were to be passed.

“If adopted unchanged, this revised rule would result in significant costs to operations that want to expand, resulting in a ‘chilling effect’ on livestock industry growth. Rather than grow in Wisconsin, producers will leave the state for more workable locations. Following the supply, meat and milk processors will move new investment opportunities to wherever that supply is.”

Regulations Applied by Local Governments

On the flip side, Scott Laeser, the water program director for environmental group Clean Wisconsin, says the regulations are “modest and long overdue.”

Just like the system is currently, new regulations wouldn’t be imposed on the farmers from the state. Local governments would have to apply them. According to Richmond’s article, new farms with more than 500 animals would have to store manure between 600 and 2,500 feet away from neighbor’s property lines. That distance could be reduced by use of anaerobic digesters or injecting manure into the ground.

Read more at newstimes.com

Conclusion

It’s an extremely complicated situation. On the one hand, one can see the importance of clean water and air. It’s important for states to step in at times and make sure these kinds of problems are kept in check- for the benefit of all who reside in Wisconsin. On the other hand, there’s only so much that these dairy farms can take. It’s been an extremely challenging series of years for hundreds of dairies across the state. Regulations like these could push dairies out of the state for good. There has to be some sort of middle ground. Like Nass is suggesting, if the state could work together with the agricultural community, maybe the two sides could agree upon a more workable and practical solution that would benefit all.

Tags: Dairydairy industryDepartment of Natural Resourcesdrinking waterfactory farmsLeague of Wisconsin Conservation Votersmanure storagemilkNational Agricultural Statistics ServicepollutionregulationsSteve NassTony EverswellsWisconsinWisconsin Dairy AllianceWisconsin Dairy Products AssociationWisconsin DNRWisconsin Farm Bureau Federation

Previous Article

Farmers are Suffering and It's Time to Take Action

Next Article

More Trade Aid on the Way

Related Content

Pork Shortage Ag Nook
Livestock

China Develops New Solution for Pork Shortage

August 21, 2019
African Swine Fever Preparation Ag Nook
Livestock

States Arm Themselves With Knowledge When It Comes to African Swine Fever Preparation

July 31, 2019
McDonald’s Sustainable Beef
Cattle

McDonald’s Sustainable Beef

July 28, 2019
USMCA Ratification Stalls
Business & Inputs

USMCA Ratification Stalls

July 8, 2019
African Swine Fever Outbreaks Continue
Hogs & Pigs

African Swine Fever Outbreaks Continue

June 28, 2019
Mexico Tariffs Off, Confusion Remains
Business & Inputs

Mexico Tariffs Off, Confusion Remains

June 23, 2019
Next Article
More Trade Aid on the Way

More Trade Aid on the Way

Newsletter

newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for AgNook top stories each week!

Top Stories

More Trade Aid on the Way

More Trade Aid on the Way

November 11, 2019
Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling

Wisconsin Dairy Industry is Reeling

September 28, 2019
Suicide Prevention Ag Nook

Farmers are Suffering and It’s Time to Take Action

September 14, 2019
Trump Delays China Tariff Increase

Trump Delays China Tariff Increase

September 12, 2019
Farmers on “Freeze Watch”

Farmers on “Freeze Watch”

September 10, 2019

Trending

Lawsuits Accuse Beef Packers of Price Fixing

Lawsuits Accuse Beef Packers of Price Fixing

April 30, 2019
Soybean Dicamba Injury Ag Nook

Tips and Tricks for Detecting Herbicide Drift

June 22, 2018
3 Crucial Tips for Cattle Water Management

3 Crucial Tips for Cattle Water Management

August 29, 2018
Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

April 15, 2018
Corn Ag Nook

Why Aren’t Corn Prices Higher?

July 18, 2018

Most Popular in the last week

Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

Pinkeye Treatment Options for Cattle

April 15, 2018
3 Crucial Tips for Cattle Water Management

3 Crucial Tips for Cattle Water Management

August 29, 2018
Recognizing and Preventing Pinkeye in Cattle

Recognizing and Preventing Pinkeye in Cattle

April 12, 2018
Land of Lincoln Has New Dicamba Restrictions

Land of Lincoln Has New Dicamba Restrictions

March 7, 2019
Cattle Grazing Systems AgNook

The Secret to Successful Grazing

November 15, 2018
Facebook Twitter
AgNook.com

  • Terms of Use
  • Contact
  • About AgNook
  • Advertise With AgNook
newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for AgNook top stories each week!

© 2018 AgNook, LLC

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Livestock
    • Crops
    • Business & Inputs
  • Markets
    • Market News
    • Market Analysis
  • Livestock
    • Cattle
    • Hogs & Pigs
  • Lifestyle

© 2018 AgNook, LLC

Don't miss out on AgNook top stories!
Subscribe to our newsletter to get our top news stories sent right to your inbox!